What easily digestable evidence is there in society at large for the difference the careers sector has/careers services have made to individuals and society?
Why have they continued to be 'an easy target' for so many years?
I am not implying they have made no difference, far from it.
As someone professionally engaged with the sector (as a practitioner and consultant), I would like to think and work towards ensuring I do make a positive difference to the individuals and organisations with whom I work. There are many many colleagues who do make a real difference to their clients' lives and the sector has made tangible contributions to the economy, wellbeing, research, and society, to name a few.
However, if a 'careers profession' (employability / careers guidance/development/learning/education/information... - more on terminology in a future post) has internally been in discussion for many years over its professional status, role/s, recognition; has 6 main professional associations and continues to be blamed and criticised for not meeting clients' (especially young people's) or employers' needs, the questions must arise (they do frequently in my mind): What have the publicly funded careers services (adult, young people, schools, higher education, further education etc) achieved that is valued by society? Why are their clear achievements, successes and professionalism not at the forefront of 'the general' view of careers services? Why are they often needing to justify/explain why they are needed? (based on my experience of the sector and interpretation of media publicity, debates, opinions etc).
There are many possible reasons, and politics and funding of course play a massive part.
I think we need to turn and ask ourselves - within the profession (at all levels) and others outside of the sector these questions time and again, seek out some honest answers and take the necessary action needed to (continue to) make improvements which 'the public' values. The questions above have been asked in the past - you may be reading this thinking. 'Well, I thought about this 10 years ago', if so, great, but this perhaps just reinforces my point - why 10/15... years on, do so many people (I come across at the very least), have a negative perception of the careers profession as a whole? (Though there are some good case studies and stories in the public domain of careers professionals/services making a positive impact).
I am pleased that originally, the 6 main careers professional associations came together in 2011 to form 'The Careers Profession Alliance' which aimed to develop and promote the sector's professionalism across the UK.
A few thoughts on this though:
1. Why were there ever 6 associations?
1a. Which in itself may not have been a bad thing, but was it the most effective development?
1b. Has this proliferation led to an unclear positive regard for the sector?
2. Why has one association withdrawn from this new Careers Profession Alliance?
3. Why has it taken 'a massive crisis' and cutbacks for these organisations to come together?
Whilst it is not unusual for us to take action and rally together when under siege, it's useful to ask the question, as the answers may help us prevent similar future fallout (especially as we are/the sector is supposed to be 'experts' in self-reflection, future planning, decision-making, networking, team working...and advise/s clients on these very topics). Yes, we are referring to organisations/ a whole sector/profession as opposed to an individual or relatively small group but the principle is the same.
What do you think?! I look forward to your answers and thoughts.
As always, I invite you to contact me and for us to make any positive changes (however small) we can - afterall each of us makes up society.